
Glenstone Lodge
Best for families and visitors who want to be within walking distance of Gatlinburg attractions and convention/event venues.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Glenstone Lodge is a family-friendly, full-service lodge in walkable downtown Gatlinburg with indoor and seasonal outdoor pools and on-site casual dining; this guide suits travelers who want easy access to attractions and event space. Black Bear Lodge by Jackson Mountain Rentals is a 3.5-star lodge-style vacation home in Cosby for people seeking a Smokies lodge stay outside central Gatlinburg and closer to river-based recreation.
Updated

Best for families and visitors who want to be within walking distance of Gatlinburg attractions and convention/event venues.

Best for travelers wanting a Smokies lodge experience outside Gatlinburg with easy access to river activities and nearby national-park trailheads.
When Glenstone Lodge wins: pick Glenstone if you want walkable access to downtown Gatlinburg, a year-round indoor pool plus a seasonal outdoor pool, an on-site family restaurant, and a large slate of event/wedding venues.
When Black Bear Lodge by Jackson Mountain Rentals wins: choose Black Bear Lodge if you prefer staying in Cosby for quieter river access, nearby rafting and ecotour options, and a lodge-style vacation home that includes an arcade/game room and an on-site restaurant.
Bottom line: both properties fit a Smokies lodge trip but serve different needs—Glenstone is the convenient, amenity-rich choice in Gatlinburg; Black Bear Lodge is a mid-tier Cosby option for guests focusing on outdoor river activities and a quieter base outside the main tourist strip.
| Category | Glenstone Lodge | Black Bear Lodge by Jackson Mountain Rentals |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Family-friendly downtown lodge with event spaces | 3.5-star lodge-style vacation home in Cosby |
| Location | Within walking distance of Gatlinburg attractions and ~0.4 miles from Great Smoky Mountains NP entrance | In Cosby, a short drive to Great Smoky Mountains NP and river activities |
| Size | 200+ rooms across multiple floors; large meeting/event capacity | Studio (6 Bedrooms) listing (unit-based vacation home) |
| Ages | All ages welcome; family-friendly pools and dining | All ages (not adults-only) |
| Pools & hot tubs | Year-round indoor pool (dual-level with waterfall) + seasonal outdoor pool; hot tub with 10–11 PM adult-only hour | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Mountain Trail Grill & Pizza on site (casual American; breakfast & dinner) | One on-site restaurant; casual dining available |
| Spa / wellness | No dedicated spa; hot tub only | Not published |
| Known for | Walkable access to downtown Gatlinburg, event/wedding facilities, family pools | Proximity to rafting, Pigeon River activities, and a recognizable 'Black Bear' Smokies lodging theme |
| Accessibility & parking | Wheelchair access with elevator; free self-parking for guests | Wheelchair accessible – no; free self-parking |
| Check-in / check-out | Check-in from 4:00 PM; check-out by 11:00 AM | Check-in begins at 4:00 PM; check-out at 10:00 AM |
Glenstone Lodge sits within easy walking distance of downtown Gatlinburg attractions and a short walk to the national park entrance.
Choose Glenstone for direct access to downtown Gatlinburg and quick park access.
Black Bear Lodge by Jackson Mountain Rentals is located in Cosby, outside central Gatlinburg, closer to river recreation and quieter stretches of the park.
Pick Black Bear Lodge if you want a quieter base near river activities rather than walkable downtown access.
Glenstone Lodge offers a range of room types across more than 200 guest rooms to suit families and groups.
Glenstone provides standard hotel rooms with family options and on-property services.
The supplier listing shows Black Bear Lodge as a vacation-home style property listed as 'Studio (6 Bedrooms)'.
Black Bear Lodge reads like a self-contained vacation-home unit rather than a multi-room hotel.
Glenstone Lodge has its own casual on-site restaurant serving breakfast and dinner.
Glenstone suits families who want convenient, casual on-site meals after sightseeing.
Black Bear Lodge includes one on-site restaurant according to the supplier listing.
Black Bear Lodge provides a basic on-site dining option, but detailed dining information isn’t published in the supplier data.
Glenstone Lodge focuses on pool amenities for families, with both indoor and seasonal outdoor options.
Glenstone is a clear pick if hotel pool access and family swim time are priorities.
Black Bear Lodge’s supplier listing emphasizes nearby river and outdoor activities rather than published on-site pools.
Black Bear Lodge is positioned for guests who plan to use nearby river recreation rather than hotel pools.
Glenstone provides limited wellness offerings and easy access to Gatlinburg nightlife and attractions.
You get pool/hot-tub-based relaxation on site and downtown nightlife a short walk away.
Black Bear Lodge’s listing highlights outdoor-experience access and in-unit comforts rather than a spa or nightlife.
Black Bear Lodge is better for outdoor-focused days and low-key evenings rather than a built-in spa or vibrant nightlife.

Glenstone Lodge — walk to Gatlinburg attractions, the Space Needle, aquarium and trolley service.

Black Bear Lodge — closer to Pigeon River rafting, islands, and other river-based recreation.

Glenstone Lodge — year-round indoor pool with waterfall plus a seasonal outdoor pool and hot tub.

Black Bear Lodge — a 3.5-star Cosby vacation home option with an arcade/game room and private-unit conveniences.
Glenstone Lodge — it’s within walking distance of downtown Gatlinburg attractions and has a trolley stop in front.
No — the supplier listing shows Black Bear Lodge as a studio-style vacation-home listing (Studio (6 Bedrooms)), not a multi-room hotel.
Yes — Glenstone has Mountain Trail Grill & Pizza; Black Bear Lodge’s listing notes one on-site restaurant, though specific menu and hours aren’t published in the supplier data.
Black Bear Lodge — Cosby location and the supplier listing highlight nearby rafting operators and river access.
Explore how Glenstone Lodge stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·