
Glenstone Lodge
Best for families who want easy walking access to Gatlinburg attractions and a straightforward lodge experience.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Glenstone Lodge is a family-friendly, walkable Gatlinburg lodge with indoor and seasonal outdoor pools; read this if you want easy access to downtown attractions and family amenities. Smith Creek Resort is a high-rated luxury cabin-style resort in Sevierville with private pools, hot tubs, and a complimentary water park; read this if you want private, upscale cabins and lots of on-site water features.
Updated

Best for families who want easy walking access to Gatlinburg attractions and a straightforward lodge experience.

Best for groups or families who prefer private luxury cabins with in-unit pools and resort-style water amenities.
When Glenstone Lodge wins: Choose Glenstone Lodge if you want to be within easy walking distance of downtown Gatlinburg, attractions like the Space Needle and Ripley’s Aquarium, and you need a family-friendly, lodge-style property with indoor pool access year-round.
When Smith Creek Resort wins: Choose Smith Creek Resort if your group wants cabin-style privacy, private pools or hot tubs in the accommodation, plus resort amenities such as a lazy river, on-site water park access, and multiple hot tubs.
Bottom line: Pick Glenstone Lodge for location and a classic Gatlinburg lodge that suits families and events; pick Smith Creek Resort for a more private, luxury-cabin stay with strong water attractions and larger, self-contained units.
| Category | Glenstone Lodge | Smith Creek Resort |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Family-friendly mountain lodge, casual | Upscale resort-style cabin property |
| Location | Downtown Gatlinburg; walkable to attractions and park entrance | Centrally located in Sevierville, near Pigeon Forge attractions |
| Size / rooms | About 200+ rooms across multiple floors (hotel listing varies) | Not published |
| Who it's best for | Families, wedding or group events, walkable sightseeing | Groups/families wanting private cabins and in-unit pools |
| Pools & water features | Year-round indoor pool plus seasonal outdoor pool and hot tub | Private pools in many cabins, 1 indoor pool, 2 hot tubs, lazy river and complimentary water park access |
| Restaurants & bars | On-site Mountain Trail Grill & Pizza (casual American; no full bar) | No on-site signature restaurants published in supplier listing |
| Spa / wellness | No full-service spa published (hot tub only) | Not published |
| Event & meeting space | 10,000+ sq ft of event space including ballrooms and River Deck Pavilion | Not listed as a primary event venue in supplier listing |
| Accessibility & family rules | Welcomes children of all ages; adult-only swim hour nightly; pets not accepted (service animals OK) | Adults only: false; pet fees/deposits apply (service animals exempt) |
| Check-in / check-out | Check-in from 4:00 PM; check-out by 11:00 AM | Check-in begins 4:00 PM; check-out 10:00 AM |
Glenstone Lodge sits in downtown Gatlinburg with short walks to top attractions and a trolley stop at the front door.
Choose Glenstone for the most convenient access to Gatlinburg’s downtown and park entrances.
Smith Creek Resort is centrally located in Sevierville and close to Pigeon Forge attractions by short drive.
Pick Smith Creek if you want easy driving access to Sevierville and Pigeon Forge attractions.
Glenstone Lodge offers a range of hotel rooms and suites geared to families and couples.
Glenstone is a traditional hotel with many room types aimed at family stays.
Smith Creek Resort lists multi-bedroom luxury and executive cabins with private pools and mountain views.
Smith Creek is oriented to groups who want multi-bedroom cabin-style units and private pool access.
Glenstone has an on-site casual American restaurant for breakfast and dinner.
Glenstone covers basic, on-site dining needs with a casual restaurant suitable for families.
Smith Creek’s supplier listing highlights shared kitchen facilities in cabins and common area refrigerators/microwave — no signature restaurant published.
Expect to self-cater in private cabins or drive to nearby Sevierville/Pigeon Forge restaurants.
Glenstone’s pool setup suits families who want both year-round indoor swimming and a seasonal outdoor pool.
Glenstone is best if you want guaranteed indoor swimming any month and a family pool atmosphere.
Smith Creek emphasizes private pools in cabins plus resort water attractions.
Smith Creek is stronger for private pool access and resort-style water features for groups.
Glenstone provides basic wellness features and family-minded evening options but no full-service spa.
Glenstone works if you want simple wellness amenities and easy access to local nightlife.
Smith Creek lists hot tubs and water amenities but does not publish a dedicated spa facility.
Smith Creek focuses on in-cabin relaxation and water amenities rather than a staffed spa.

Glenstone Lodge — walk to Gatlinburg attractions, trolley stop at the door.

Smith Creek Resort — multi-bedroom cabins with private pools and rooftop lounges.

Glenstone Lodge — indoor pool open year-round (plus seasonal outdoor pool).

Smith Creek Resort — lazy river, complimentary water park access and multiple hot tubs.
Glenstone Lodge is explicitly family-friendly with an indoor pool open to all ages and a casual on-site restaurant; Smith Creek also welcomes families but focuses on private cabins and may charge pet fees if applicable.
Yes—Smith Creek Resort lists Luxury and Executive cabins with private pools. Glenstone Lodge offers indoor and outdoor public pools but not private in-room pools.
Glenstone Lodge has extensive event space (ballrooms and a River Deck Pavilion) for weddings and large gatherings. Smith Creek’s supplier listing does not highlight comparable event facilities.
No full-service spa is published for either property; both list hot tubs and water amenities but not a named spa facility.
Explore how Glenstone Lodge stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·